Skip to content

Analysis · Regulation

What the SEC staff said about protocol staking in May 2025, and what it left out

On 29 May 2025 the SEC's Division of Corporation Finance said certain protocol staking activities do not involve securities offerings. The statement covers solo, self-custodial and custodial staking, excludes liquid staking and restaking, and has no legal force.

By Etherelysium Editorial TeamUpdated 18 November 20264 min read

What the SEC staff said about protocol staking in May 2025, and what it left out
Share X LinkedIn

For years the question of whether staking ETH could turn a token or a service into a securities offering hung over US staking businesses. On 29 May 2025 the staff of the Securities and Exchange Commission’s Division of Corporation Finance published a Statement on Certain Protocol Staking Activities. It is narrower than many summaries suggest, and the narrowness is the useful part.

What the statement covers

The staff describe three arrangements as “Protocol Staking Activities”:

  • Self (or solo) staking, where the holder runs a validator with their own assets.
  • Self-custodial staking directly with a third party, where the holder keeps custody and delegates validation to an operator.
  • Custodial arrangements, where a custodian stakes on the holder’s behalf.

The staff’s view is that these activities “do not involve the offer and sale of securities” under the Securities Act of 1933 and the related provision of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. The statement also addresses ancillary services a provider may offer alongside staking: slashing coverage, early unbonding, alternate reward payment schedules and amounts, and aggregation of assets to meet minimum staking amounts.

What it leaves out

The statement says plainly that it “does not address all forms of ‘staking'”, naming liquid staking, restaking and liquid restaking as outside its scope. For Ethereum, where much staked ETH sits behind liquid staking tokens, that exclusion matters. Any reading of the May 2025 statement as covering stETH-style tokens, or restaking protocols built on top of them, goes beyond what it says.

It is also a staff statement. In its own words it “has no legal force or effect” and does not alter or amend applicable law; the Commission “has neither approved nor disapproved its content”. Staff views can be revised. Courts are not bound by them.

Context: guidance is not a classification

The legal test in the background is the 1946 Howey decision, which asks whether people invest money in a common enterprise expecting profit from the efforts of others. Staff statements like this one explain how staff apply that test to a described set of facts. They do not replace it, and they do not settle the separate question of how ETH itself is classified, which is what market-structure legislation such as the CLARITY Act tries to address by statute.

How the three models differ for the person staking

The three arrangements look alike from the outside, because in each of them ETH ends up securing the network and earning protocol rewards. They differ in who holds what. In self staking the holder controls both the validator’s signing key and the withdrawal credentials, runs the software and carries the full operational risk: missed duties cost small penalties, and a misconfiguration that signs conflicting messages can lead to slashing. In self-custodial staking with a third party, an operator runs the validator and holds the signing key, while the withdrawal credentials point to an address the holder controls, so the stake can only be withdrawn back to the holder. In a custodial arrangement the custodian controls both, and the holder relies on the custodian’s records and its promise to pass rewards through.

The staff reason that the work a node operator or custodian performs in these arrangements is administrative or ministerial in nature, rather than the managerial effort of others that the Howey test looks for. That reasoning is tied to the facts the statement describes. Whether a particular product matches those facts is the question that matters, and it is answered by the product’s terms of service, not by its marketing.

Questions to put to a staking provider

  • Which of the three described arrangements is this, in the provider’s own terms of service?
  • Who controls the withdrawal credentials, and to which address can the stake be withdrawn?
  • Who bears a slashing loss, and is any slashing coverage a contractual promise or a discretionary policy?
  • Are rewards passed through as the protocol pays them, or paid on a schedule the provider sets?
  • Does the provider issue a token that represents the staked position? If so, the statement’s exclusion of liquid staking applies to that token.
  • What fee is taken, and is it a share of rewards or a fixed charge?

None of these answers turns a product into a security or out of one. They tell you whether the product in front of you is the one the staff described, which is the only thing the statement speaks to.

Keep the answers together with the date you checked them. Terms of service change, and a provider that adds a token, a pooled product or a new reward scheme may move from a described arrangement into one the statement does not cover.

The Settlement Test, applied to guidance

What settles: nothing in law; the statement records how staff view the described activities. What it costs: little for activities that match the description; for anything outside it, liquid staking or restaking included, the earlier uncertainty remains. What breaks: a business model that relies on the statement while doing something it does not describe, or that assumes staff views cannot change.

How to use it

Match the arrangement in front of you against the three described models. Note which ancillary services are involved. If a liquid or restaked token is part of it, the statement does not speak to that layer. For how staking itself works and what its yield figures omit, see what a staking yield leaves out and our guide to how Ethereum staking works. This is information, not legal advice.

Primary sources

Educational content, human-edited and possibly AI-assisted. It describes how systems work and is not financial, legal or tax advice. Report an error via our corrections page.

More in Regulation

Related articles

See all