
Arbitrum One, OP Mainnet and Base are usually listed together as the large optimistic rollups. They share the basic model: execute off-chain, post data to Ethereum, assume posted states are valid unless someone proves otherwise. The differences sit in the dispute machinery and in who can override it, and those differences decide how long an exit takes and what happens if something fails.
The shared model
Ethereum’s documentation on optimistic rollups describes the general case: withdrawals must wait until “the challenge period, lasting roughly seven days” has passed, and the chain’s validity “relies on the existence of one honest node”. Users who do not want to wait can sell a pending withdrawal to a liquidity provider, who pays them on L1 for a fee. Each project tunes the specifics.
Arbitrum One: BoLD
Arbitrum’s dispute protocol is called BoLD. The project documentation describes it as a protocol that “enables permissionless validation” and states that it is active on Arbitrum One. Disputes are designed to conclude within a 6.4-day window, which the documentation notes the DAO can change. The documentation frames the worst case as bounded: two challenge periods, plus a two-day grace period during which the Security Council can intervene, plus a small allowance for computation. The Security Council’s ability to intervene is the override to watch.
OP Mainnet: permissionless fault proofs and a Guardian
According to the Optimism documentation, fault proofs were activated on OP Mainnet on 10 June 2024. Proposals are submitted through a DisputeGameFactory contract and face a challenge period of about one week. After a game resolves, an additional “airgap” delay applies before withdrawals can be finalized, during which the Guardian role can reject the result. The documentation names the Optimism Security Council as the Guardian, able to pause withdrawals, blacklist dispute games, or fall back to a permissioned system if the proof system fails.
Base: a shorter path when two proofs agree
Base is built on the same OP Stack, but its documentation on transaction finality describes a different withdrawal clock: a finalization window of five days for a single-proof dispute game, and one day on a “dual-proof fast path” when both a TEE-based proof and a ZK proof back the same proposal. The same page breaks down confirmation on L2: inclusion in an L2 block after roughly 200 milliseconds, a batch posted to Ethereum after roughly two minutes, and L1 batch finality once that Ethereum block is more than two epochs old, about 20 minutes.
What the comparison shows
None of these windows is better or worse in isolation. A short exit window is good for users who need to leave quickly and only safe if the proof system and its overrides are sound. A long window gives watchers more time to dispute and users more time to react to a bad upgrade. The figures above are what each project’s documentation says when we read it on 18 November 2026; they can change by governance vote or upgrade, which is why we link the source rather than treat them as permanent.
Independent risk dashboards such as L2BEAT track these parameters across rollups, including exit windows and what happens if the sequencer or proposer stops. When a dashboard and a project’s own documentation disagree, read both and check the contracts.
The Settlement Test
- What settles: each rollup’s batches and state proposals on Ethereum. An L2 transaction is final for L1 purposes once its batch sits in a finalized Ethereum block; a withdrawal is final once that rollup’s dispute window (and any airgap) has passed.
- What it costs: L2 execution plus the L1 data fee per transaction, and for exits either days of waiting or a liquidity provider’s fee. Compare current costs with our L2 fee comparator and the L2 comparison table.
- What breaks: a halted sequencer pauses each chain until forced inclusion is used; a Security Council or Guardian can intervene in disputes or withdrawals, which is a safety net and a trust assumption at once.
For the underlying concepts, see optimistic rollup, fraud proof and our guide to reading L2 finality and settlement. Token pages: ARB, OP.
Primary sources
Educational content, human-edited and possibly AI-assisted. It describes how systems work and is not financial, legal or tax advice. Report an error via our corrections page.


